Skip to content

Sunday School dunce Joe Cole taught a lesson by ‘Le Professeur’s’ pet Samir Nasri

August 17, 2010


The saying goes that “There are no atheists in foxholes”, and some may argue that when it comes to football, “there are no simpletons playing in the hole”. Well, we would all like that to be the case, but unfortunately, Joe Cole managed to supply reason to suggest otherwise.

Plotting against him was Samir Nasri, impressive throughout pre-season, rejuvenated from his omission from the the French World Cup squad (dodged a bullet there), carried his form through to the new season with an impressive display against Liverpool.


By contrast, Joe Cole, who played the similar role for his Liverpool team, desperately struggled for the 45 minutes he was on the pitch before getting sent off (dodged a bullet there). He thrashed around the central areas of the pitch, straining to receive the ball, constantly closed down by Arsenal’s midfield tight midfield trio of Diaby, Nasri and Wilshere.

His worthlessness can be seen by examining his passing; he did not manage to make a pass past the opposition’s centre-circle, showing how deep he had to come to receive the ball. Elements of his game that he showed against FK Rabotnicki Skopje were shown, his creativity, quick feet and movement were instead replaced with inadaptability and enthusiasm that lead him to more often than not running into Arsenal’s midfield.

His disappointing league debut was forced by Arsenal’s high defensive line and tight midfield, restricting all time and space Cole thought he may have had in the middle of the park. Suffocated by Diaby and his own inability to drift wide (more on this later), he buckled and committed footballing suicide by lunging at Arsenal centre-back Laurent Koscielny.

Poor Joe Cole, with lanky Abou Diaby clambering all over his small-frame, treating him like a kids climbing frame, there was never any hope for him.

He looks like he’s had enough after 7 minutes and loses the ball, one of many times.

In contrast, Liverpool sat deeper, allowing Nasri more freedom to move into dangerous areas of the pitch. The result was that passes could find Nasri easily, giving him more time on the ball, presenting him the opportunity to pass the ball in the attacking third, making him a lot more dangerous than his counterpart Joe Cole. Nasri had much more of an influence over the game, orchestrating passing moves, unfortunately for Arsenal, his conducting led to nothing more than rendition of ‘World’s saddest song, played in world’s smallest violin’.

The deeper line that Liverpool operated against Arsenal could be seen as dangerous, by sitting deep and inviting pressure, teams find it hard to disrupt Arsenal’s passing and to win back the ball. Teams that employ a deep line are usually hoping for one of those ‘Arsenal off-days’, where the incision and patience on the ball does not result in goal-scoring opportunities. It was one of those days on Sunday.

Liverpool’s deep defensive line offers Samir Nasri space to work with.

Of course, this is not to say that Samir Nasri had a ‘world-class’ game – he didn’t. He failed to play any defence-splitting passes or create any clear chances and credit has to be given to Liverpool’s organisation and compact shape in the defensive third.

The advantage of sitting deep is that it allows the team to keep its shape and restrict the spaces behind your defence (think of Inter vs Barcelona in the semi-final of the Champions League). In a way, managers, when setting their team-up against Arsenal face a trade-off between space in midfield or space behind your defence. Hodgson chose to restrict the space behind the defence, making it difficult for Arsenal to find the final ‘killer’ ball. Barcelona opted for the different approach, of pressing high and closing down when each player had the ball, and it worked for them. This approach differed to the manner opted for by ex-Liverpool manager Rafael Benitez.

Roy Hodgson’s different approach when playing Arsenal

The strategy employed by Roy Hodgson of sitting deeper is different to the one implemented by Liverpool’s former manager, Rafael Benitez. Benitez looked to press-high up the pitch and work hard to win the ball back, offering players little time on the ball. Hodgson’s approach gave Arsenal more time on the ball in the middle of the park, resulting in fewer unsuccessful passes, allowing them to dominate possession.

Think back to the 2-1 win at Anfield last season for Arsenal. In the first half Liverpool were playing the football that brought success in the latter half of the season before, they constricted the space and forced the opposition to rush and misplace passes. It was a tactic that had worked well for Benitez, think to the 4-4 at Anfield, remembered because of Arshavin’s goalscoring exploits. What was overlooked was the fact that Liverpool harassed them and Arsenal played very poorly, unable to string together passes in midfield and defence, the vital areas where they start their ‘spinning top’ of passing and movement.

Back to Joe Cole, my ‘Sunday School Dunce’

What Joe Cole needed to do in Sunday’s ‘high line, high pressure situation ‘is just take some time to think about what his movement can do to help his team What needed to click was that his position is very flexible, he can move around the pitch without Liverpool losing a shape or creating any weaknesses in the team structure. Effectively, what he does without the ball is just as important as what he does with the ball, which is where game intelligence is needed to manipulate a an opposition’s shape to create weaknesses and potential opportunities.

I’ve written before about Mesut Özil, the blueprint of an intelligent attacking midfielder, and how in tight defences he moves out to the flanks, dragging midfielders out with him thus creating space for players to move into. It is this sort of movement that was needed, but was desperately lacking throughout.

He also could have realised that he could join David N’Gog up-front, looking to run onto the balls over the top of the Arsenal defence, making the Arsenal defence more wary about the long-ball, as well as dragging a central midfielder out of position (Diagram 1).

A further implication of this is that it causes the defence to drop deeper as they’re wary of runs from deep, giving space for a midfield partner to move into (Diagram 2), giving the opportunity for Steven Gerrard to drive into central areas where his powerful runs often create something. Instead, he just shuffled around in central areas, looking stifled and frustrated.

This does not bode well for his chances of shifting the label that has been put on his forehead by Carlo Ancelotti, that he’s a bit ‘thick’. Perhaps it was the fact that it was his league debut, that he wanted to be on the ball in the middle and get involved, but he did not help Liverpool take advantage of the high-line played by Arsenal. This lack of game intelligence shown by Cole was magnified with his ill-judged attempt at blocking the ball in the dying stages of the first half. I just hope that Joe Cole has his books and pens ready, for he is going to have to be taught a lesson by Mr. Hodgson on how to play football given his performance on Sunday.

6 Comments leave one →
  1. Grant permalink
    August 17, 2010 6:15 pm

    Great Analysis.

    I think that Joe will end up playing most of the time on the wing for Liverpool. And as a Liverpool fan I hope that he was just trying too hard to get into the game.
    Playing that deep was very dangerous like you said. And if Fabregas had been playing then it could have been very different.
    This Liverpool side is still finding its identity under Hodgeson. Especially the midfield, with there being one holding midfielder (Lucas, Poulsen and at the moment Mascherano) then where do you fit Gerrard and Cole. And what about Aquilani, he still has something to offer in the ‘hole’.

    • August 17, 2010 7:04 pm

      I don’t think Cole will though, I don’t think he’s particularly great on the wing. I just think he was trying too hard to be involved on Sunday, which made him do stupid things.

      I think Gerrard will continue to play in the central midfield area, but last season, after people were having a go at Benitez for playing him an advanced position, he played a series of games there and was shoddy (vs Wigan, in particular).

      I see us sticking with the 4-4-1-1 that we saw during pre-season and at his time at Fulham. Cole will just fit in behind the striker whilst Aquilani can play in Gerrard’s position and in Cole’s. Aquilani is great in advanced positions, if a little erratic, he sees some terrific passes that others in our team can’t, as well as being able to score. I hope we get to see him at his best this season, he’s a terrific player when he’s on form.

      • Grant permalink
        August 17, 2010 8:49 pm

        Its funny as the team seems to be set up to accommodate Cole not Gerrard.

        You only have to look at the England Hungary game to see how effective Gerrard can be in the hole position.

        One problem with Aquilani when he plays is that he doesn’t contribute defensively. That leaves us with 3 players who best play behind the striker.

        One other thing, It looks like Jovanovic and Kuyt are the main wing players, both are hard working and good defensive. Interesting how that may be set up so the midfield can be more attacking with the wide players possibly filling in if there is a gap, eg. Gerrard burst forward, gets caught out but Kuyt can drop back to cover.

        There are enough options and cover to the midfield and attacking positions now, its only the defence to worry about. Theres still Maxi and Babel who can play a number of positions.

  2. Mish permalink
    August 19, 2010 5:45 pm

    Interesting article but you neither can nor should judge a player on their first league performance for a new club.

    There are so many variables to take into consideration that it makes analysis useless.

  3. August 19, 2010 5:48 pm

    Cheers Tim, great post – technical but not boring. Keep’em coming.

  4. August 21, 2010 9:34 am

    Excellent article, thanks.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: